•
John Caluda

How King Cake Became a New Orleans Obsession

How King Cake Became a New Orleans Obsession

From colored sugar and cream cheese to crawfish, celebrity-chef collaborations and thousands of contest votes, king cake has become much more than something to serve at a party.

In New Orleans, people take time off of work to buy cake.

On January 6, 2026, the opening day of the Mardi Gras season, local television reporters found customers waiting in bakery lines that stretched around corners. Some were collecting stacks of king cakes for friends and family. Others had rearranged their workday to make the trip. (FOX 8)

To an outsider, it might resemble the excitement surrounding concert tickets or a limited-edition sneaker release. In New Orleans, it means king cake season has begun.

There are favorite bakeries to defend, new flavors to investigate and rules to argue about. Does the cake need filling? Does the baby belong inside or beside it? Should the knife stay in the box? And when, exactly, is eating a slice acceptable?

The cake itself has become equally complicated. A king cake party table might hold a cinnamon braid, a cream-cheese-filled ring, an almond-filled French pastry or something stuffed with boudin. In 2026, even Dubai chocolate had entered the local king cake lineup. (Eater New Orleans)

How did a familiar reason to gather around a table become something people pursue, debate and campaign for?

The answer involves generations of bakers changing a tradition—and customers giving them reasons to keep going.

The Cake People Remember

King cake’s roots reach into European Epiphany traditions, long before any modern New Orleans bakery. But for many New Orleanians who grew up in the twentieth century, the reference point was closer to home: McKenzie’s. (64 Parishes)

In its documentary Nostalgic New Orleans Eats and Drinks, WYES traces McKenzie’s larger-scale king cake sales to 1936, following a request from the Twelfth Night Revelers. People interviewed for the program remember a relatively plain, bread-like cake topped with purple, green and gold sugar. For its admirers, the simplicity was part of the appeal.

Pastry chef John Caluda’s first king cake was McKenzie’s.

He remembers being in first grade when someone handed him a paper plate holding what looked like a slice of French bread topped with gold sugar.

He had no idea what a king cake was—or that it would become so intertwined with his life.

He just knew he liked it.

When Tradition Started Changing

Other bakery traditions increasingly emphasized sweeter dough, cinnamon and icing. One influential family recipe traces its beginnings to a St. Bernard Parish bakery opened in 1965, where a braided king cake topped with icing became a signature product. (The bakery’s published family history)

Even before the filling debate, “traditional” could depend on which bakery someone grew up visiting.

The Controversy Over Fillings

The filled-king-cake boom gathered momentum in the 1980s, with more than one bakery participating in the breakthrough.

In Gambit’s history of filled king cakes, columnist Blake Pontchartrain identifies two origin stories dating to 1983.

At Jodase Bakery and Catering in Metairie, owner Joan Seeman said the first experiments were apple and pineapple. She told The Times-Picayune in 1989 that her husband took four cakes to work and that the bakery received 25 calls within half an hour.

Around the same time, brothers Angelo and Tony Cartozzo were working on Danishes when they tried putting Bavarian cream into a king cake. Their mother tasted the result and wanted more made immediately.

Other bakeries developed their own filled versions. By about 1988, even McKenzie’s was offering several flavors.

Not everyone applauded. In a 1988 column recalled by Pontchartrain, writer Ronnie Virgets poked fun at the increasingly embellished king cake, using the word “dandified.”

Even in the 1980s, New Orleanians were already debating whether a king cake should have filling at all.

The audience was expanding, too. Research published through Louisiana Folklife documents the growth of commercial king cake shipping during the 1980s, as Louisiana families sent a taste of Mardi Gras to people living elsewhere.

Bakers had more potential customers—and more reasons to distinguish their cakes.

When Jazz Fest Met King Cake

The inspiration for Caluda’s crawfish king cake came from another New Orleans tradition: Jazz Fest.

Caluda began serving Crawfish Strudel at the New Orleans Jazz & Heritage Festival in 1997. (Caluda’s King Cake) A few years later, he recalls, a late Carnival season overlapped with festival preparations at Coffee Cottage on Metairie Road. The kitchen was making crawfish strudel filling while king cakes were still in production.

Caluda places the experiment around 2000, although he is not certain of the exact year. He and pastry cook Ronald Gregory wondered whether that filling could work inside king cake dough—or perhaps a richer brioche.

The filling worked. The remaining challenge was making a savory cake look like Mardi Gras without covering it in sugar.

Caluda believes Gregory suggested coloring grated Romano cheese purple, green and gold. He says Coffee Cottage was the first bakery to use colored Romano cheese as a king cake topping.

The cheese preserved the familiar Mardi Gras colors while complementing the crawfish filling. It changed not just what went inside the cake, but how the entire cake could be presented.

He also recalls securing protection for the Crawfish King Cake name. Coffee Cottage accompanied the cakes with a Crawfish History Scroll and individually numbered them. Caluda remembers the numbered series reaching roughly 1,900.

The experiments attracted attention beyond the bakery. In 2014, Eater New Orleans featured Caluda’s crawfish and muffuletta king cakes, greeting the savory departures—and the colored Romano cheese—with comic alarm.

As Coffee Cottage’s king cake business grew, Caluda says, producing the crawfish version continuously became difficult. Today, it returns for occasional appearances during Carnival season.

What once sounded unlikely had become something customers waited to see again.

Savory Becomes a Category

Crawfish was not the only Louisiana flavor to find a place inside king cake.

Boudin brought another regional favorite into the conversation, taking the filling in a very different direction from cream cheese or fruit. The variation is established enough that Louisiana’s tourism organization publishes a boudin king cake recipe in its culinary collection.

Caluda’s eventually developed its own version of Boudin King Cake using Best Stop Boudin from Scott Louisiana near Lafayette. John describes it as an existing idea adapted in his own way.

Alongside crawfish and muffuletta, boudin helped expand what customers could expect from a king cake. The question was no longer simply which sweet filling belonged inside.

It was whether the cake needed to be sweet at all.

     

A New Reason to Come Back Next Week

At Caluda’s, experimentation eventually acquired a schedule.

John credits bakery manager Lesley Foryinsky with the idea of featuring a rotating Flavor of the Week. Instead of offering only the same choices throughout Carnival, the bakery could give customers another reason to return.

His son Josh joined the bakery in 2016, Caluda says, and developing flavors became an increasingly collaborative effort. He credits Lesley and Josh with one of the team’s newer creations, Pumpkin Spice King Cake.

The weekly rotation is documented in a 2019 report on Caluda’s seasonal lineup, which listed Oreo Cream Cheese, Maple Bacon Praline, Bananas Foster, Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough and White Chocolate Bread Pudding among successive specials.

The schedule changed the question a customer might ask. It was no longer only which bakery made a favorite cake. It was also what that bakery was making this week.

Bananas Foster offers a particularly New Orleans example. Brennan’s created the famous restaurant dessert, and Caluda says it is a family favorite that he frequently prepares for family and friends. Turning those familiar flavors into a king cake was a natural step—and Caluda says his bakery did it first.

Caluda’s Bananas Foster King Cake was already on its published flavor calendar in 2019. Brennan’s debuted its own version in 2022. (NolaNow; FOX 8)

A dessert associated with a restaurant dining room had acquired another life in a Carnival cake box.

Good Ideas Don’t Stay in One Bakery

Caluda has seen that exchange from both sides.

He points to Crawfish King Cake, Bananas Foster, Chocolate Fudge Brownie and Red Velvet among the king cake flavors his bakery was making before he began seeing similar versions appear elsewhere. Developing something unexpected—and watching customers respond—has been a major part of his work.

For Caluda, part of the satisfaction comes from reading positive comments and seeing customers discuss the new flavors online. The enjoyment is not just in creating something different, but in seeing other people get excited about it.

He also acknowledges the inspiration behind some of his other creations. Bywater Bakery’s Chantilly King Cake inspired Caluda’s interpretation. The cannoli idea came from Nor-Joe Importing Company. Boudin was another existing concept the bakery adapted in its own way.

“We all get ideas from each other,” Caluda says.

That back-and-forth helps explain how the selection grew so dramatically. Bakeries contribute their own creations while finding new possibilities in what others are doing. A familiar dessert becomes a filling. A savory dish becomes a king cake. Another baker takes the idea in a different direction.

Social media has accelerated the process, Caluda observes. A new cake can be photographed, shared and discussed far beyond the bakery where it first appeared. Customers and fellow bakers no longer need to visit the shop to discover its latest experiment.

The next idea can come from anywhere. And once it catches people’s attention, it rarely stays in one place.

The Icing Has Been Evolving, Too

The filling gets much of the attention, but the changes have not all been hidden inside the cake.

Caluda points to an equally dramatic evolution on top.

The range now extends from colored sugar with no icing to basic sugar icing, chocolate glaze, white-chocolate-flavored icing, buttercream, caramel and the rich cream-cheese icing people associate with cinnamon rolls. Whipped ganaches add another texture, while increasingly elaborate decorations and garnishes give bakers more ways to distinguish their creations.

The topping is no longer simply a finishing touch. It can help define the cake’s flavor, texture and appearance.

A cake can be familiar underneath and something entirely different on top.

The dough is another opportunity. Caluda’s experiments include chocolate and red velvet doughs, with additional colors and flavors in development.

The pursuit of something different now reaches through the entire cake, from the dough to the last decoration.

More Than One Kind of King Cake

Not every variation follows the same historical path.

The French galette des rois, made with puff pastry and almond filling, belongs to an older Epiphany tradition. It is not a recent offshoot of New Orleans’ filled ring; it offers a different interpretation alongside it. (64 Parishes)

Vietnamese-American bakeries have also broadened the local range, including distinctive folded-dough cakes, horseshoe shapes and cream-cheese icing. These are additions to a diverse baking community, not a single recipe shared by every Vietnamese-American bakery. (Eater New Orleans)

Size has become another choice. Some customers need a large or super king cake centerpiece for an office party. Others want an individual cake, a format already documented in Louisiana reporting from around 1990. (Louisiana Folklife)

The category has room for the customer feeding a crowd and the person who simply wants a piece of Carnival without a week of leftovers.

Restaurant Chefs—and the Next Generation—Join In

The experimentation now reaches beyond bakery kitchens into culinary classrooms.

For the 2026 Carnival season, chef Frank Brigtsen collaborated with the culinary-arts students and faculty at the New Orleans Center for Creative Arts, or NOCCA, on a Strawberry Tres Leches King Cake. It combined fresh strawberries, tres leches custard and strawberry jam inside the school’s dough. Brigtsen was NOCCA’s first chef-in-residence and has remained involved with its culinary program. (NOCCA Foundation)

The same season brought Emeril Lagasse’s Banana Cream Pie King Cake, translating another recognizable restaurant dessert into Carnival form. Proceeds from NOCCA’s king cake program supported its Culinary Arts department.

     

The collaborations show another way ideas circulate: established chefs contribute experience while students learn to develop, produce and sell their own interpretations.

International trends are arriving, too. NOCCA’s 2026 offerings included a Dubai chocolate king cake incorporating pistachio, chocolate and kataifi, the fine strands of pastry that contribute crunch. (Eater New Orleans)

Caluda sees flavors such as pistachio, Biscoff and Dubai chocolate as part of the next wave bakers are exploring.

The inspiration may travel a long way. The finished cake still arrives dressed for Mardi Gras.

Eventually, New Orleans Started Making Fun of Itself

The endless possibilities have also become comedy material.

The fictional Larry Ragusa king cake commercials parody the increasingly outrageous creations. NPR’s 2016 coverage of king cake culture singled out the fake bakery advertisements as part of the city’s self-satire. (GBH)

The joke works because the premise is familiar: somewhere, another baker is considering something nobody has thought to put inside a king cake.

And somewhere else, a customer is already asking when it will be ready.

The Rules May Be as Complicated as the Recipes

For all that freedom, king cake comes with a remarkable number of expectations.

The traditional season runs from January 6 through Mardi Gras. Some people take that boundary seriously. Others test it with holiday cakes and off-season slices. Folklore supplies consequences: historian Rien Fertel records the warning that eating king cake out of season brings rain on Mardi Gras Day. (64 Parishes)

Caluda describes more extravagant versions involving hurricanes or a losing Saints season. The forecasts are part of the joke.

Even leftovers can become a matter for consultation. In February 2026, a New Orleans Magazine writer asked local cultural authorities whether a cake purchased before Mardi Gras ended could properly be finished afterward. They said yes. The fact that the question required consultation says something about the subject.

Then there is the baby. The familiar custom makes its finder responsible for supplying the next cake. (FOX 8)

Caluda says customers sometimes call because nobody found one. A baby genuinely may be missing, he allows. But he suspects that, more often than not, somebody found it and simply does not want to admit it.

Finding the baby is exciting—until someone remembers whose turn it is to buy.

Icing produces its own arguments. In Caluda’s experience, putting on too much draws complaints, but reducing it does not necessarily end the discussion. Someone else will ask where the rest of it went.

Even the serving utensil has a protocol. The insistence that the knife remain in the box is recognizable enough to have inspired knives carrying the instruction. (The New Yorker)

A city willing to put crawfish inside a king cake can still have firm opinions about where to leave the knife.

When Cake Gets a Campaign

The intensity becomes especially visible when people vote.

In 2022, Caluda’s won FOX 8’s NOLA Weekend King of Cake Challenge, taking the final round with 51 percent of more than 42,000 votes after five weeks of competition. FOX 8 reported that supporters returned every eight hours to vote, with some setting alarms to make sure they did not miss their opportunity. Friends and families around the country joined the effort. (FOX 8)

It is one thing to have a favorite cake. It is another to set an alarm for it.

The King Cake Snob winners archive provides another record of the bakery’s following. Caluda’s won Best Filled in 2016 and at least one of the contest’s two principal categories in every year from 2018 through 2025, with victories for both traditional and filled cakes.

Caluda’s also won New Orleans Magazine’s 2026 King Cake Madness bracket.

The argument that once happened around an office cake box can now produce thousands of votes. People are not simply choosing something to eat. They are championing a bakery, a flavor and sometimes a childhood memory.

The Old Cake Is Still There

After the crawfish experiments, the weekly flavor rotations and the competition campaigns, Caluda’s still makes an Old School King Cake.

It is baked with colored sugar on top, without icing.

For John, it brings the story back toward that first-grade paper plate and the McKenzie’s slice with gold sugar. A career spent exploring what else a king cake could become has not eliminated the appeal of a simple one.

That may be the most revealing part of the evolution.

The old cake was not replaced by crawfish, cannoli or Dubai chocolate. It now shares the table with them.

New Orleans just kept adding to it.

The choices have become more complicated, but the invitation is still recognizable: cut a slice, pass the cake and find out who is bringing the next one.

Just leave the knife in the box.

 

Sources and Further Reading

This article draws on the published sources below and firsthand recollections provided by chef John Caluda. Personal memories and accounts of Caluda’s product development are attributed to him in the text.

  1. FOX 8: Long Lines Form at Popular Bakeries as Carnival Season Starts — January 2026 coverage of opening-day king cake demand.
  2. Eater New Orleans: The Best King Cakes in New Orleans — Contemporary king cake styles, specialty flavors and bakery offerings.
  3. 64 Parishes: King Cake — Historical background, Epiphany traditions and Louisiana king cake customs.
  4. WYES / PBS: Nostalgic New Orleans Eats and Drinks — Documentary material on McKenzie’s and its place in New Orleans food history.
  5. St. Bernard Parish bakery family history: Our Family History — The family’s account of its original bakery and king cake tradition.
  6. Gambit / NOLA.com: Blake Pontchartrain: King Cakes With Fillings Started Showing Up in the 1980s — Early filled-cake accounts involving Jodase Bakery and the Cartozzo family.
  7. Louisiana Folklife: From Custom to Coffee Cake: The Commodification of the Louisiana King Cake — Research on changing king cake traditions, commercial production, fillings and shipping.
  8. Caluda’s King Cake: About Caluda’s — Bakery background and the Jazz Fest connection.
  9. Eater New Orleans: This Horrifying King Cake Will Give You Nightmares — Humorous 2014 coverage of Caluda’s crawfish and muffuletta king cakes.
  10. Explore Louisiana: Boudin King Cake — A savory king cake recipe from Louisiana’s tourism organization.
  11. NOLA Now: King Cake Season: Eight Places for New King Cakes to Try in 2019 — Coverage including Caluda’s published Flavor of the Week schedule.
  12. FOX 8: King Cake Season: See the New King Cakes Rolling Out for Carnival 2022 — Coverage of new offerings, including Brennan’s Bananas Foster King Cake.
  13. Bywater Bakery: Chantilly King Cake — The bakery’s product listing.
  14. NOCCA Foundation: Chef Emeril Lagasse and Chef Frank Brigtsen Join NOCCA’s Culinary Arts Students and Faculty for the 2026 King Cake Season — Official announcement of the chef collaborations and support for culinary education.
  15. YouTube: Larry Ragusa’s King Cakes — Commercial 3 — The fictional king cake commercial referenced in the article.
  16. NPR / GBH: New Orleans: A City in the Grip of King Cake Madness — Reporting on king cake culture, experimentation and local satire.
  17. New Orleans Magazine: Eating King Cake Outside of Carnival Season — Discussion of seasonality and the question of finishing leftover cake after Mardi Gras.
  18. The New Yorker: A Crowning Moment for the New Orleans King Cake — Coverage of contemporary king cake culture, including the knife-in-the-box custom.
  19. FOX 8: Caluda’s Wins 2022 NOLA Weekend King of Cake Challenge — Competition results and reporting on supporters’ voting efforts.
  20. King Cake Snob: Past Winners — The contest’s published archive of category winners.
  21. New Orleans Magazine: King Cake Madness — The magazine’s king cake bracket competition.